Former lawmakers scrap redistricting measure

Two former lawmakers scrapped plans Tuesday to ask voters to revamp how the state’s congressional and legislative districts are crafted. Ken Clark and Roberta Voss stopped gathering signatures for their initiative drive, which would have forced the creation of more politically “competitive” districts.

Judges reject Democrats' redistricting argument

These are districts where there are a relatively equal number of registered Democrats and Republicans.

But Voss, a Republican, said they haven’t given up on the underlying goal. Instead, she said, they hope to reach a deal with others who now oppose their measure in hopes of coming up with something that all sides can find more acceptable.

That could be placed before voters in 2010.

The decision by the two former legislators already has had one effect: Current state Rep. Jonathan Paton, R-Tucson, said he will scrap his plan to put a competing measure on the ballot this November, which would have done exactly the opposite of what Clark and Voss proposed.

“There’s probably some middle ground,” said Clark, a Democrat.

Central to the question is what factors should be considered when drawing district lines.

A 2000 ballot measure created a five-member commission to create the 30 legislative districts and eight congressional districts. That voter-approved measure required consideration of several factors, ranging from comply with federal voting rights laws to protecting “communities of interest.”

It also said that, if possible, the commission should create politically competitive districts.

Based on that, the commission created only a handful of competitive legislative districts. Legal efforts to overturn those districts have so far failed.

The initiative would have made creation of competitive districts the top priority, something Clark said could have created 11 competitive legislative districts.