East Valley Tribune - Metro Phoenix's East Valley region

Metro Phoenix's East Valley region

Saturday, Nov 21, 2009| 1:57 pm

Search:

Publish your Stuff

Log in| Become a member| Help

Cop Shop| Chandler| Gilbert| Mesa| Queen Creek| VarsityXtra| Education| Dining| Valley| Nation & World| Get Out| Multimedia| Special Reports| Coupons Veterans Day| Senior Life| Celebrities| Games| Weather| Traffic| Info Center| Crosswords| Comics| Weird| Find a rack location| Send feedback| Help Desk

Freedom of speech tested at Obama rally

Madelyn Burke, For the Tribune

October 19, 2007 - 8:41PM , updated: October 20, 2007 - 10:13AM

Digg| Save| License| Print| E-mail| Decrease text size Reset text size Increase text size

An 18-year-old university student held his ground - and onto his Ron Paul t-shirt - despite efforts of security guards to remove him from Sen. Barack Obama’s rally Friday at Arizona State University campus.

View slideshow.

Obama well-received at ASU rally

Barack Obama addresses crowd of 6,000 at ASU

Jacob Done, 18, stood atop a tower in the center of Hayden Lawn on ASU campus proudly displaying a “Ron Paul Revolution” T-shirt above his head as Obama, D-Ill., began to speak to the crowd. First, security approached Done asking him to step down from the window ledge on top of the tower for safety reasons, but then they insisted he leave after he stepped to a lower platform, Done said.

Three men wearing purple ProEM Security staff shirts attempted to remove Done by grabbing him, but Done resisted the force. At the time, Done was standing next to a reporter for the Tribune.

Bystanders yelled in support, saying “Let him stay,” and “It’s free speech!” Security guards eventually agreed to let him stay on the tower along with others who came to see Obama speak, as long as he kept his Ron Paul shirt no higher than his head, saying it would obstruct the views of others if held any higher.

Security guards did not appear to approach people holding Obama signs high above their heads.

“Once he got down, he wasn’t causing a disturbance,” said Maegan Kearns, 23, a secondary education major at ASU. “Everybody, even the Democrats, rallied around the Republican to support free speech.”

Done said he had figured his actions might cause a ruckus, but he didn’t foresee it going so far.

“I expected people to hold their signs up, like trying to block my shirt like they did at very first,” Done said. “I didn’t expect them to bring security in to try to take me out.”

When asked to comment on the situation, one of the security guards who attempted to remove Done said, “no comment,” and “no one from our company will tell you anything.”

Other ProEM staff also refused to comment. And representatives at the company’s Tempe headquarters had no comment when called by the Tribune.

Austin Franke, 21, a bystander at the rally who witnessed the incident, said: “I totally disagree with them asking him to leave. I mean obviously this is a rally for Barack Obama, but this is still America, and he should have the right to express whatever view he wants.”

“There were a thousand people here with signs, he wasn’t the only one holding something up over his head,” Franke added. “The fact that they singled him out, I think, is just kind of suspicious.”

Done said he came to the rally to hear what Obama had to say, but held his shirt high to show that he supports Paul more.

Other Paul supporters gathered near the Obama rally, and some said they were refused entry to the event.

“We weren’t allowed in because our signs said Ron Paul, and I feel it’s a lack of freedom of speech here,” said Jadon Kelly, 17, who remained outside the rally for the entirety of it and held his sign high above his head.

April Lam, 25, who was holding her Ron Paul sign alongside Kelly, said she was told there were no signs allowed.

“I saw posters that people made themselves that said ‘Barack Obama,’” Lam said. “It’s just the fact that it said Ron Paul that it wasn’t allowed in. It wasn’t the fact that it was a sign because, as you saw if you were in there, there were tons of signs up.”

Comments

Reader comments: This site does not necessarily agree with comments posted below. Responsibility lies solely with the comment author.

Please add your comments, but follow these guidelines to keep this a safe, credible place for discussing the news:

  • Stay on topic.
  • No personal attacks, racial slurs or insults; no vulgar, lewd or threatening comments.
  • Report abusive comments.

Reader comments (27)

This site does not necessarily agree with comments posted below. Responsibility lies solely with the comment author.

My comment disappeared! What's going on?


View more comments:  1|  2|  3

Vince

I don't feel like I'm living in America anymore. Cops taser kids, harass people, and arrest anybody they want.

Ron Paul will stop ALL of this!

RonPaul2008.com Suggest removal of this comment
October 20, 2007

i support Ron Paul..but....

Ron Paul will stop federal support of all these things you guys list... He'll leave it up to the states to decide... this in turn could be a good thing, or a horrible thing.... think about it! lets say a state like Alabama sees it fit to prosecute drug users or Gays to the highest extent... don't expect the federal government under Ron Paul to have you back in this case.... Hopefully states will become more liberal on these cases, but not all will.... i mean segregation could re appear in parts of the south and the Federal government wont do anything about it! Under Ron Paul you will see very diverse communities pop up and this could be a big problem...say good bye to civil rights! Of coarse some states will stay liberal on civil rights but not all will...
the good things that the government does that we take for granted might not be there for us.... Suggest removal of this comment
October 20, 2007

Todd Stallion

"segregation could re appear in parts of the south"

No. Segregation was discrimination by the government which was allowed BECAUSE OF FEDERAL GOVERNMENT LEGISLATION.

So your point is not valid. It was Plessy v. Ferguson that allowed Jim Crow laws. That is a federal law.

For Godsake SLAVERY was allowed only because of FEDERAL LAW. And even when it was abolished in the North, the FEDERAL Government enacted the Fugitive Slave Act which made it Federal Law to send slaves back from Free States.

Your argument is phony.

"...say good bye to civil rights! "

I don't know what Country you live in but Civil Rights are the Constitution and NOBODY defends the Constitution more than Ron Paul. Comment has been reviewed
October 20, 2007

BS DESTROYER!

Senator Obama will put an END to the war mongering by the rePUKE scum bags!

CALL THE WHITE COATS FOR THESE LUNATICS...TELL EM TO BRING PLENTY OF STRAIT JACKETS!

FOX ATTACKS! Iran

http://foxattacks.com/blog/10777-fox-attacks-iran Suggest removal of this comment
October 21, 2007

BS DESTROYER!

You are such a LIAR...you remind me of GOP lie machine;

http://foxattacks.com/blog/11968-the-best-compilation-of-bush-administration-lies-about-iraq-i-ve-ever-seen

In short, as is clear to ALL; You are an UNEMPLOYED loser over the age of 30 ....still living with mommy and daddy....which projects his frustrations on others...
Suggest removal of this comment
October 21, 2007

Jack

The confusion about freedom of speech can be easily understood:

Freedom of speech occurs on PUBLIC LANDS only.

Simple. Private land such as the churches mentioned, can kick you out for embracing Ron Paul. On the University Lawns however, PUBLIC LAND must endure freedom of speech.

So, if Obama decided to host a private fund- raising event on private property, then he and his friends may remove the Ron Paul support.
(Usually, honesty and forthrightness is removed as well when Paul is escorted out of the building...)

Jack
Yet another supporter of Ron Paul's campaign Suggest removal of this comment
October 22, 2007

Aaryck

FYI-Obama volunteer here. Truth is there were not signs allowed in the event all the signs were made by the Obama Camp volunteers prior to the event for the crowd. We made the hand made signs...every single one of them and those who chose to use them was entirely up to them. The security should have never give Done a problem to begin with. He does have the right to speak and like Senator Obama mentioned before that Republicans are welcome to join also. That's what's so great about him. Suggest removal of this comment
October 23, 2007
View more comments:  1|  2|  3


More blogs

Publish your photos

Phoenix Light Rail Debut Phoenix Light Rail Debut
By Desertdawg from Ahwatukee

Vigilantes Kill 5 Vigilantes Kill 5
By BigAve from Gilbert AZ

Dinosaur Tracks Dinosaur Tracks
By BigAve from Gilbert AZ

Abby comes home Abby comes home
By Desertdawg from Ahwatukee

Publish your videos

More forums

Here's your chance to brag about an achievement for you or someone you know.

Publish your honors

Read the latest print edition

The e-Trib is an interactive online representation of the printed paper. Editions can be searched back to 2002.

Launch the e-Trib viewer

Already a member? Sign in here
Publish your stuff
Welcome, Please Log In
To login please enter your username and password in the form below and click on the login button.
Remember me
Retrieve Password
Resend Email
Enter the username and email address for your account to resend you your confirmation email: