I would like to relate a story that demonstrates the difference between Sen. John McCain and former Congressman J.D. Hayworth.
Social Security was deducting the premium for Medicare Part D for my husband and me. They were also deducting the same amount from our checking account. So we were being double-charged and having money removed that we needed for other expenses. We were at a town hall at the Senior Center in Scottsdale and brought our paperwork and a letter to see if we could explain the situation to Mr. Hayworth – or his staff – in the hope that he could be of some assistance. As my husband approached him and asked him if he could take two minutes to explain the situation and give copies of the appropriate paperwork to his staff, he held up his hand and said “I’m not going to discuss this with you.”
My husband asked if he could at least give the paperwork to his staff in the hopes that someone from our congressman’s office would take an interest and help us with the situation, or at least verify that we were being double billed. Again Mr. Hayworth held up his hand and said “No! Give it to my staff.” We did give it to his staff, and to this day have never heard back from them.
Several weeks later we were going downtown and brought the documents into Senator McCain’s office to see if his staff thought anything could be done. His staff was extremely gracious and warmly received us even though we had no appointment. We explained the situation and gave them the statement and copies we had prepared for Mr. Hayworth.
Within three weeks they got the situation rectified. Social Security stopped taking the premium twice and reimbursed us for the overpayment.
What reminded me of this situation was seeing Mr. McCain last Saturday at a town hall in Fountain Hills. We saw several of his constituents acting very much as we had with Mr. Hayworth — asking for a moment or two to explain a difficulty with an agency of the federal government. Mr. McCain was extremely gracious. He listened patiently and handed the documents to his staff.
If this man — who is arguably the most recognizable Republican officeholder in America, who is a senior ranking member of one of the most powerful committees in the United States Senate, who must have an extremely packed schedule — can take the time to be gracious with the people who sent him to Washington, why couldn’t Hayworth? It is clear to me from this experience why the voters of this state continue to elect McCain. He has — and will always get — our votes.
Shirley Lesser, Scottsdale
Letters policy: Click here to submit a letter. Please be brief (no more than 300 words) and type or print name, address, city and phone number for verification. Comments may be edited for clarity and length.