Barack Obama, Jan Brewer

President Barack Obama talks with Arizona Gov. Jan Brewer after arriving at Phoenix-Mesa Gateway Airport, Wednesday, Jan. 25, 2012, in Mesa, Ariz. (AP Photo/Haraz N. Ghanbari)

A couple of observations from somewhere east of Eden, er, Phoenix ...

•    •    •

Anyone who thinks Gov. Jan Brewer wasn't grandstanding when she recognized that she would have several seconds alone with President Barack Obama as he stepped off Air Force One in Mesa Wednesday doesn't know that opportunism is at the bedrock of American politics. Brewer was literally playing it for Peoria (Arizona). And she succeeded.

Months ago, Brewer had publicly invited Obama to Arizona to join her at the Mexican border for a tour and discussion of what border states such as Arizona face in dealing with illegal immigration. The president declined the tour.

So why didn't Brewer realize that after all this time the border tour wasn't going to happen? Because she never expected Obama to take her up on it. In fact, that was the last thing she wanted him to do.

If Obama had thought a moment, turned to Brewer and said, "You know, you're right! I should join you at the border. I'll probably cave in on SB 1070 as well!" the governor would have probably needed help getting up off the tarmac.

These tricks are as old as the hills. Pols of both parties employ them. An old favorite is the old empty chair ruse. One candidate sets up an empty chair at a public gathering to demonstrate his or her opponent's cowardice about participating in a debate that the opponent was invited to join in, but didn't.

"I've set up this chair," the candidate would say. "I can't imagine why my opponent isn't here! Let's look out the window and see if my opponent is driving up ... No? Well, I'm certainly surprised! Wait, let me check my cell phone ... Nope, no voice mail, no text messages. My, my, I almost certainly thought he was going to be here, didn't you?"

And so on. Of course the opponent wasn't going to show. But it's exactly that kind of situation that creates the chance for the maudlin, vote-getting appeal of a naked setup.

There was Brewer waiting at Phoenix-Mesa Gateway Airport, with her letter in hand. Obama reportedly told Brewer he didn't like her book. Nothing new in that; a lot of people don't like her book.

And a lot of people do, or, more likely, badly want to find out what's in it that Obama doesn't like: Capitol Media Services reports in the Tribune statistics from ranking it 285,568th in sales of all titles on its list as of Wednesday. That leaped to 56th by Thursday morning and to 20th by Thursday afternoon, the report said. Memo to the president: Remember, sir, that the greatest boom to sales of a book or tickets to a movie is that it was "Banned in Boston," or, in this case, "Disliked by the president."

Mesa Mayor Scott Smith said in a story by reporter Garin Groff in Friday's Tribune that the widely distributed photo of Brewer seemingly pointing a finger at Obama was a fortunate capturing of the governor moving her arm.

"As animated as the discussion was, I don't ever recall her pointing her finger," Groff quoted Smith as saying on Thursday.

If he did make a comment about the book, Obama is probably regretting it today; once Brewer handed him the letter he should have just defaulted to, "Well, I am certainly glad to be here in Arizona! Won't you join me as I shake hands with a few folks?" But he didn't.

It's not likely Brewer is going to cease inviting Obama to the Mexican border; it's too effective of a flame-fanning device for her political base. The empty chair with Obama's name on it is going to be on that stage for some time to come.

•    •    •

The state Senate passed a bill last week forbidding teens younger than 18 with less than six months' licensed driving experience - or those only with a learner's permit - to use cell phones while driving.

That teenagers talk too much on cell phones while driving, and that it is a dangerous practice, is not in dispute. But cell phones have become the scapegoat for virtually all accident-causing driving, and that's simply not true.

Teenagers only do more of what many older folks also do while driving: Apply makeup, shave, crank up the stereo, balance various foods and drinks on their laps while eating, reaching into the back seat, looking away from what's directly in front of them at any number of distractions including the opposite sex, and so on.

You won't find any of those in the bill, even though all of those - certainly combined - cause more accidents than cell phone use alone.

But cell phones are relatively new compared to all those other examples of distracted driving, and thus are more on the minds of the public as a distraction than those time-honored, less-cool-looking activities two paragraphs above.

So why pass such a law? Because politicians love to grandstand, don't they?

Read Mark J. Scarp’s opinions here on Sundays. Watch his video commentaries at Reach him at

(8) comments

Leon Ceniceros

Obama acted like the egocentric, egotistical, ill-mannered person that he always was. Did the Liberals, the Progressives, the Democrats, the Socialists, the Anarchists and the Communists who elected him expect him to act....otherwise ???

The Conservatives, the Independents who didn't vote for him weren't surprised at his boorishness...we had seen it many...many times before (remember the "white" cop bashing episode when he first came into Office).

Sadly, the manners, mores and values of the 1950's and early are not the ones enforce today. No gentleman (heck, no "man") would have turned his back on a lady in mid-sentence.

Do any of you think that Medea.....oops...I mean Michelle Obama would have let Hussein walk away from her in bet your sweet bippie she wouldn't


Greed and self-interest have been a mainstay of Arizona politicians for years. There is no reason to think that it has gone away now. Petty bickering and personal agendas take precedence over true needs of the people and meaningful issues. Jan Brewer was obviously using the moment to sell her book. What difference does it make that she had a chance to make Arizona look good in the national press for a change. Better to exploit the opportunity for personal gain. The finger wag was to make sure she got a Kodak moment. There is nothing genuine about our governor except her opportunism and disdain for her constituents.


Mark is obviously just another liberal-socialist hack who thinks that Hussein has done a wonderful job leading this country.

Given Hussein's track record in economics and leadership, I believe that whatever happened between our Governor and the POTUS was at an appropriate level of respect that he has earned unlike his Nobel award.

Rational Human

Dale says: "Mark, You got that right!" And you call yourself a conservative? You're a tax and spend liberal who probably owns several books written by cloward and piven.


You forgot to mention Obama's PLOYS: Picking up a baby for the audience and giving it a kiss; Allowing a CRIMINAL FOREIGN NATIONAL to state how we should change our laws/society to make her life easier. An AMERICAN CITIZEN should have been there.


Mark J. Scarp thinks that – ….. “once Brewer handed him the letter he should have just defaulted to,” "Well, I am certainly glad to be here in Arizona! Won't you join me as I shake hands with a few folks?"”

In a Thursday night interview with ABC's Diane Sawyer, in Las Vegas, President Obama brushed off the incident with Arizona Gov. Jan Brewer and
told ABC news; “But this was really not a big deal. She wanted to give me a letter, asking for a meeting. And I said, ‘We'd be happy to meet.’”

Gov. Brewer has not been shy about the exchange . . . which Mark now calls “Grandstanding.”

Dale Whiting


You got that right!

Leon Ceniceros

Mike....quit drinking the "purple kool-aid".

Obama doesn't "grandstand"....Mike, that's all he knows how to do. He can't lead now that the Deficit-o-crats are not running the whole show. He can't work out any compromises with the Republican House. He talks to the House Speaker once every 6 months. Instead Obama flies all over the Country week in...and week out every Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday. He comes back when the House has left for the week on Fridays so..........nothing gets done in Washington.

Putting the President's lack of manners in this meeting shows that he can't even stand and listen to a Governor for 5 minutes to ask him to come to Arizona and see the ...ILLEGAL ALIEN INVASION FROM MEXICO...........FIRST HAND.

Mike, I guess that you, like so many Arizonians who for political or religious reasons decided not to serve in the US Military, have no concept of what leadership really is. To you, the President bowing like a servant to the Emperor and Emperess of Japan and the King of Saudi Arabia and giving a speech at the United Nations apologizing for everything that America stands for is..............leadership.
Well Mike, let me tell you wouldn't know the difference between grandstanding and leadership if it bit you in the patootie.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.