Here are the four provisions of SB 1070 decided by the U.S. Supreme Court as well as comments from the court's majority ruling.

Section 2(B) requires police to try to determine the immigration status of someone they have already stopped if there is “reasonable suspicion” that person is unlawfully in the country. It also requires determination of immigration status of anyone placed under arrest. UPHELD AS WRITTEN.

“However the law is interpreted, if Section 2(B) only requires state officers to conduct a status check during the course of an authorized, lawful detention or after a detainee has been released, the provision likely would survive pre-emption -- at least absent some showing that it has other consequences that are adverse to federal law and its objectives. There is no need in this case to address whether reasonable suspicion of illegal entry or another immigration crime would be a legitimate basis for prolonging a detention, or whether this too would be preempted by federal law.”

Section 3 makes it a state crime for someone not in this country legally to fail to carry federally issued registration cards. VOIDED AS PREEMPTED.

“Federal law makes a single sovereign responsible for maintaining a comprehensive and unified system to keep track of aliens within the Nation?s borders. If Section 3 of the Arizona statute were valid, every State could give itself independent authority to prosecute federal registration violations. . . . Even if a State may make violation of federal law a crime in some instances, it cannot do so in a field (like the field of alien registration) that has been occupied by federal law.”

Section 5(C) makes it a crime for an undocumented worker to apply for work in a public place or perform work as an employee or independent contractor in Arizona. VOIDED AS PREEMPTED.

“Congress made a deliberate choice not to impose criminal penalties on aliens who seek, or engage in, unauthorized employment. A commission established by Congress to study immigration policy and to make recommendations concluded these penalties would be 'unnecessary and unworkable.' . . . . Congress decided it would be inappropriate to impose criminal penalties on aliens who seek or engage in unauthorized employment. It follows that a state law to the contrary is an obstacle to the regulatory system Congress chose.”

Section 6 lets police make an arrest without a warrant if there is “probable cause” they committed an offense that makes them removable from the country. VOIDED AS PREEMPTED.

“This state authority could be exercised without any input from the Federal Government about whether an arrest is warranted in a particular case. This would allow the State to achieve its own immigration policy. The result could be unnecessary harassment of some aliens (for instance, a veteran, college student, or someone assisting with a criminal investigation) whom federal officials determine should not be removed. This is not the system Congress created.”

(15) comments


the female students bored while walking in the street and saw an ad street, a well-known foreign companies looking for a beautiful young


Its a nice one . Thanks for sharing


While I agree, I think being on a diet doesn't really help to add to the issue. Anyway, good point.


While I agree, I think being on a diet doesn't really help to add to the issue. Anyway, good point.


I think most people don't realize the effort that goes into creating websites like the East Valley Tribune. There goes a lot of time in writing good articles on hard subjects.


“Congress made a deliberate choice not to impose criminal penalties on aliens who seek, or engage in, unauthorized employment. A commission established by Congress to study immigration policy and to make recommendations concluded these penalties would be 'unnecessary and unworkable.' . . . . Congress decided it would be inappropriate to impose criminal penalties on aliens who seek or engage in unauthorized employment. It follows that a state law to the contrary is an obstacle to the regulatory system Congress chose.” Louis Vuitton Handbags Outlet Louis Vuitton Handbags Louis Vuitton Purses


Results, someone could even shamelessly proposal stupidity farming Why do not phoned home quickly send money over the guy completely stupid farming as two hundred and fifty, and city people like to just the city's rural people as two hundred fifty.

Stupid old-fashioned farming, does not know that guy is in completely to him as a two hundred fifty stupidity farming only strongly feel that if we remitted the money, it was his disgrace would rather die than from stupid farming recommend this guy, very disgusted, that hurt his self-esteem.

6, stupid tillage thought, to actually pique wildly readily to hand over their identity cards and 250 dollars.

Whether stupid farming know do not know, two hundred fifty this statement, stupidity farming so when the back two hundred and fifty, that wage is so stupid farming also it stupid farming also thought to charge his identity card and a deposit of 250 dollars, would force him to move so well done in the Far East will last longer, is not necessarily a good thing.

Stupid farming pay the ID card and 250 dollars, and officially became the Far East to move so the employees, it was stupid farming the registration arrangements and asked stupid plowing the time being stay here, to have older employees to take him to live place.

Them a little stupid farming talking about what matters stupid Geng also did not think of that, what matters, stupid farming go with the flow was almost not to think about what the problem anyway escorted ID card and 250 dollars, stupid farming that deposit, will not allow him to have any ideas, stupidity farming still immersed in which emotion to find work, the thought no longer need to worry about anything, everything will adapt over exceedingly comfortable, stupid farming has never been so careless.

Stupid farming in the door at the bench and that middle-aged men suffer sitting in a stupid farming would like to know more about that middle-aged men, stupid farming actually do not like to take the initiative to understand others, that middle-aged men The mind is heavy, do not want to say anything stupid farming more than obviously somewhat taboo, much coach factory outlet online to let it go out.

Stupid farming only preliminary learned that middle-aged man is Cantonese, is also just officially became the Far East to move so the employees, but not stupid coach outlet online farming points in a group, the stupidity farming unclear how Cantonese recruited, there are coach factory online no escorted ID card and a deposit of 250 dollars, that Cantonese is obvious to the Far East to move so the job a few more in mind, is not optimistic this stage of life in which he, as well as experience, the stupidity farming can not imagine, he to coach factory outlet Cantonese this age, but also in moving houses, looking for a move so stupid farming which stage of life, let what coach outlet online him regardless of experience, should experience a little anxious to promising pressure, said white little purpose to work as laborers, like stupid farming to catch up with the proper degree of maturity for his age, quickly grew up in the community, more not a little anxious to have sterile pressure, it is not to have coach outlet to work to earn money. .

Yu Geng told the Guangdong people consonance, no need to lay bare, with the horizon self less Meet mention the deja vu.

8, twelve hours later, an old staff rushed to the scene, you want this to go to a place to live with the stupidity farming and Cantonese.

Old staff is still young, but bony, blue overalls, wearing a short-sleeved shorts even more distress Liao down, the surface look dull bosses in front of moving houses in the Far East, Cited Well Well, loyal, and did not dare delay, tarry, they hastily took stupid farming and Cantonese to live where the seems not stupid farming and Cantonese slightest interest.

Leave the office, stupid farming and Cantonese are each picking up coach outlet store two sets of overalls, but still know nothing about the matters related to that anyway, the future will slowly understand, do not have suspicious.

9, from the cheap coach purses office came out, stupid farming further learned that it the Cantonese was originally a formal job, because laid-off coach factory only to Guangzhou to work very optimistic that Cantonese Far East to move so the job, if he were with his life experiences, it is necessary to understand the move so the job than the stupidity farming in the Far East more Cantonese chatter Susu with stupid Geng said, give it a try anyway, to feel bad, it certainly will be dismissed out that Cantonese move so the job of the Far East, there is no settled down, variables.

Stupid farming mouth wanted from that older employees learned about the Far East to move so this work, stupid farming generally do not like to find out from someone else, but stupid farming is actually very mouth from others to find out what happens, and that old employees but why do not want to reveal about the Far East to move so the job, vague buzzing murmur, the old employees just talked to dry to move so the line not alone contribute on the line, but also speaking skills, Do not break something that older employees seem to be seen, stupid farming even picking up two sets of overalls ID card and a deposit of 250 dollars, even if the country does not guarantee the into had to move so this line seems to imply stupidity farming should think coach purses outlet into had to move so would not join this line, variables, and even more do not have to talk about wages like.

Stupid Geng also did not think he found the job of the Far East to move so will this line into the move so stupid farming no such mental preparation, stupid farming feel like the older employees who he can be seen that the Far East move house job is how nature, he definitely has that older employees do not become the kind of look that older employees will become the kind of look into moving houses line, he do not care in moving houses this line .

Far louis vuitton purses East to move so the job is the first job stupid farming work, stupid farming can be a strong sense of the Far East to move so significant job, almost indicates how about the prospect of his work, indicates his ability to work how samples should be treated carefully, emotions are running high, stupidity farming heart in addition to the Far East to move so the job, and then have no other ideas....

north face outlet

Stay warm for less with North Face closeout jackets and Kids North Face Denali clearance. The North Face jackets sale might include a North Face Denali sale or a North Face Khumbu sale, which is always everyone's favorite thing in the entire world.Mens North Face 2 In 1 clearance Seriously, getting a North Face Denali on sale is better than getting an A in physics. Ok, maybe not better than an A in physics,Mens North Face 3 In 1 clearance but probably better than a C- in history. The North Face sale is totally equal-opportunity, too, so there are plenty of Women's North Face Sale Jackets,Mens North Face Apex Bionic clearance Mens North Face Sale Jackets, and Kids North Face Sale Jackets to go around.Stock up on North Face clothing at closeout prices at Mens North Face Clearance clearance. Find seasonal clothing and year-round duds at the Women's North Face Clothing Sale and Mens North Face Denali clearance. And, there's bound to be some pretty special play clothes to be found at the Kids' North Face Clothing Sale.

fake oakley

The North Face Clearance present you with the best security and preserve you far from the cold wind and weather. This windproof fleece The North Face Outlet incorporates a higher repute specifically for the faithful outside sports activities fanatics. Now the cheap north face is hot available for sale using the lower price within our
cheap north face on sale outlet online now. Please be happy to pick out your preferred jackets now and you can get low price fine quality delicately packing no sale tax and door to door delivery. Occur on with any hesitation. buy Cheap North Face Jackets online deliver uncomplicated convenience and durability for winter-weather effectiveness.

Rational Human

Julio is calling all police in AZ racist Nazis and the trip is allowing this? Is this how the trib feels about AZ cops? Is calling people Nazies now allowed. You had better start editing these people out of this paper if you want to have a credibility at all. Calling the police Nazis is no different than calling black people N-ggers.

Dale Whiting


See how ignorant our Neo-cons are! Here Leon invites Sheriff Joe to go back to his practice of profiling. If he does, Judge Bolton will re-enter her injunction and the Supremes will can the fourth provision challenged, too. That is how ignorant our Neo-con friends are!


So close down border patrol...close down ICE too. Why not? According to you folks there is no longer a need for them. Then , stop checking id's at the airport coming and going. Also, close down homeland defense because need for it because this is no longer a country of laws anymore. If there is a law and you break it...just invoke executive priviledge. Hey.....let,s just open up all the borders! You can't discriminate right? Good luck border towns!, wahoo...I am going to hire a non resident to work in my house because .....I can

Leon Ceniceros

Come on Sheriff have your mandate from the Supreme Court of the United States of America.

GET THOSE "TRAFFIC STOPS" ([wink] ...out there in South Phoenix and the side roads coming up from Pinal and Pima County for the 4th of July (heck, it's as good as an excuse as any....let Holder and Grijalva and them criticise =

Wait till you have about 100 Illegals then call all the TV Stations and have them waiting with cameras as you bring them to a hoot to see Wolf Blitzer, Anderson Cooper, and all the MSNBC Guru's go bananas...........[beam]

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.