A bid to deny citizenship to the children of illegal immigrants faltered Monday when proponents could not get the votes of a Senate panel.
After more than three hours of testimony at the Senate Judiciary Committee, Sen. Ron Gould, R-Lake Havasu City, yanked the two measures from consideration. Gould told Capitol Media Services he could not get the backing of four other members of the Republican-controlled panel, which he chairs.
Gould said, though, he is not giving up. And Senate President Russell Pearce, R-Mesa, said that, if necessary, he will reassign the proposal to a more friendly committee.
The failure of the measures came despite Gould allowing a Chapman University law professor to argue for more than an hour that there is no legal basis for the current practice of giving citizenship to all children based on the location of their birth. John Eastman said passing the two measures proposed by Gould would finally give the nation's high court a chance to address squarely the scope of the 14th Amendment.
It says that children born in this country and "subject to the jurisdiction thereof'' are considered U.S. citizens.
Gould and Pearce contend that was never the intent of the crafters of the measure approved after the end of the Civil War. Instead, they said is was solely to clarify that former slaves and their children were entitled to citizenship despite a pre-war Supreme Court decision declaring the contrary.
One proposal would define Arizona citizenship -- and, by extension, U.S. citizenship -- as linked to having at least one parent who can prove U.S. citizenship or permanent legal residency. The other would set up a system where birth certificates were marked as to whether they prove citizenship, with states agreeing to honor each other's notations.
Even before any testimony, Sen. Adam Driggs, R-Phoenix, said the proposal, based on that idea of Arizona citizenship, raises a host of unanswered questions.
"I don't understand how you become an Arizona citizen if you move to Arizona, what the bureaucratic model would be,'' he said. "Do you then need to bring your own birth certificate and both of your parents' birth certificates?''
There also were a parade of children opposed to the bill, including 12-year-old Heide Portugal who said she was born in this country but her parents were not and that a measure like this, had it been in effect, would have denied her citizenship.
But the proposals also drew opposition from the business community.
Kevin Sandler, president of Exhibit One, openly worried about the message that adopting such a law would send.
Sandler said his firm, which provides audio-visual equipment to courts across the nation, had to lay off six employees after some out-of-state firms boycotted Arizona businesses after lawmakers adopted SB 1070 last year. That measure gives police more power to detain illegal immigrants.
Sandler said, though, another boycott is just a part of the problem.
"We've created a toxic environment,'' he told lawmakers. "Businesses don't want to move here.''
He said companies looking to relocate pay attention to the political climate in a state.
"What we've really done is create a not-open-for-business environment here,'' Sandler said.
And Glenn Hamer, president of the Arizona Chamber of Commerce and Industry, told legislators they should not take up this fight and instead leave the question of citizenship where it belongs: in Congress.
Aside from Eastman, all of the testimony against the measures was in opposition.
Latino activist Salvador Reza said the debate over which children are entitled to legal recognition is "not very dissimilar to the debate that happened in South Africa not to long ago, not very dissimilar or different from the debate that happened in Nazi Germany not too long ago.''
"Young kids like this were denied citizenship for whatever reasons,'' Reza said.
Jennifer Allen, executive director of the Border Action Network, said denying citizenship to children born in this country based on a parent's citizenship would create "a permanent underclass'' of people in the state.