Arizona abortion clinic search being questioned - East Valley Tribune: Arizona

Arizona abortion clinic search being questioned

Print
Font Size:
Default font size
Larger font size

Posted: Wednesday, March 12, 2014 8:44 am | Updated: 3:14 pm, Tue May 20, 2014.

A bill in the Arizona Legislature to allow surprise inspections of abortion clinics has been described by supporters as a vital tool for health inspectors, who now must get a warrant to make unannounced searches of abortion providers.

But the Arizona Department of Health Services has sought only one abortion clinic search warrant in the past four years — and it happened just days before the bill was heard in the House of Representatives last month. The warrant was in response to a low-priority report filed nearly 11 months ago by Planned Parenthood of Arizona, and critics believe the search was purely political to help sell the proposal to lawmakers.

"It is very clear that it was not a situation which merited getting a warrant," Planned Parenthood of Arizona President Bryan Howard said. "It would seem that the only reason that warrant was sought was that so that the Department of Health could testify three days later about going through the warrant process. So really it was a trumped-up situation."

Health Services denies that there is any link between the legislation and the search. Spokeswoman Laura Oxley said the agency originally planned to obtain a warrant in November, but it was delayed, in part to ensure that a team of inspectors was available to do the search.

"This is the first administrative search warrant we've served, and we carefully worked through the process," Oxley said. That included working with the attorney general's office and a local court, and coordinating with a local police agency to serve the warrant.

The search warrant bill is being pushed by the Center for Arizona Policy, the conservative group that wrote a now-vetoed religious freedom bill that angered gays, civil rights proponents and the business community. President Cathi Herrod said it is needed to protect women from rogue doctors like Kermit Gosnell, a Philadelphia physician found guilty last year of murder in the deaths of three babies prosecutors said were delivered alive and killed.

Rep. Debbie Lesko, R-Peoria, is sponsoring the legislation, which passed the House last week and is set for its first Senate committee hearing this week. She has said repeatedly that abortion clinics should be subject to the same unannounced inspections without a warrant that all other medical facilities in Arizona can face.

"This is not a pro-life versus pro-choice issue," Lesko said. "This is about the healthiness of a facility where a woman goes to get a procedure done."

Democrats say the bill is a smoke screen and that the snap inspections would lead to harassment of women seeking abortion services.

The health department has received just five complaints concerning abortion clinic safety in the past three years, and the recent case at Planned Parenthood was the only time a warrant was carried out. It was in response to a report submitted by Planned Parenthood last year about a complication that a patient experienced.

Oxley said the report was considered a low priority but worthy of eventual follow-up. But the warrant, issued Feb. 7 and executed Feb. 10, said "it was imperative" that the agency be given unannounced and immediate access to Planned Parenthood's Glendale clinic for a search.

During the search, Health Services staff hauled off records of policies, two patients, compliance audits and a corrective action plan dated May 8, 2013.

Oxley said the investigation remains open, and no citations or "notices of deficiencies" have been issued.

The restrictions on abortion clinics are in place as part of a 2010 settlement of a federal lawsuit brought after earlier state legislation. The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals found snap inspections at the state's abortion clinics are illegal because women's privacy rights are particularly at risk.

But the Center for Arizona Policy argues circumstances have changed and the unannounced inspections could be upheld as constitutional. House Republicans who voted 34-22 for the bill last week embraced that argument, with just one Republican, Rep. Kate Brophy McGee, breaking ranks.

Planned Parenthood has warned that if passed, the law just sets up another lawsuit that the state must pay to defend.

Arizona abortion clinics normally are inspected every year as part of the licensing process but can get a one-year extension if no problems are noted. If complaints are received, regulators can seek to inspect earlier or ask a judge to issue a warrant.

The Health Services employee who testified last month described a burdensome process where the department had to call in the state attorney general's office, then go to a judge for the warrant.

But a former Maricopa County Superior Court judge said warrants can be obtained extremely quickly at all hours, either in person or by telephone. Retired Judge Kenneth Fields also noted the U.S. Supreme Court and other courts have made it clear that authorities can go in without a warrant in cases when they have a reasonable that belief people's lives are in danger or that evidence might be destroyed.

"I've done this for 40 years, and I'm telling you, if there is a legitimate, reasoned basis to get a search warrant, you can obtain it very quickly, as both police officers, lawyers, judges know," Fields said.

Oxley said because the department had never sought a warrant before, it didn't know exactly how the process worked, and the judge also was unfamiliar with the administrative warrant process.

© 2014 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

More about

More about

More about

  • Discuss

Attorney General Forum - Question 1

Attorney General candidates Republican Mark Brnovich and Democrat Felecia Rotellini debate at ...

Your Az Jobs